| Ancient |
|
Modern |
While recording the tradition, interprets their meaning for the
tribe. |
|
Attempts to reconstruct past events objectively and
accurately. |
Uses oral sources with few written documents or lists. |
|
Relies on documents and written records. |
Can include several parallel versions of the same story. |
|
Sorts out the conflicting accounts in order to find the single
"right" one. |
Gives rough approximations of dates and places. |
|
Carefully searches out the chronology and locations. |
Relies on fixed types of literary descriptions or motifs. |
|
Tries to get "behind" the literary genres and narrative modes to
find out what really happened. |
Uses a "common sense" approach that is not dependent on every
fact. |
|
Uses all the critical tools and means of information to check
sources and their claims. |